Article,
Aliases of the first eccentric harmonic : Is GJ 581g a genuine planet candidate?
(October 2010)
Abstract
The radial velocity (RV) method for detecting extrasolar planets has been the most successful to date. The RV signal imprinted by a few Earth-mass planet around a cool star is at the limit of the typical single measurement uncertainty obtained using state-of-the-art spectrographs. This requires relying on statistics in order to unearth signals buried below noise. Artifacts introduced by observing cadences can produce spurious signals or mask genuine planets that should be easily detected otherwise. Here we discuss a particularly confusing statistical degeneracy resulting from the yearly aliasing of the first eccentric harmonic of an already-detected planet. This problem came sharply into focus after the recent announcement of the detection of a 3.1 Earth mass planet candidate in the habitable zone of the nearby low mass star GJ 581. The orbital period of the new candidate planet (GJ 581g) corresponds to an alias of the first eccentric harmonic of a previously reported planet, GJ 581d. Although the star is stable, the combination of the observing cadence and the presence of multiple planets can cause period misinterpretations. In this work, we determine whether the detection of GJ 581g is justified given this degeneracy. We also discuss the implications of our analysis for the recent Bayesian studies of the same data set, which failed to confirm the existence of the new planet. Performing a number of statistical tests, we show that, despite some caveats, the existence of GJ 581g remains the most likely orbital solution to the currently available RV data.
